Reflection of Winter

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• parasbhalla (38525)
• [2011-01-16 5:45]

Another beautiful work where B&W treatment to the picture worked so well, Julie!
Great mirror-reflections and perfect clarity.
The contrast between the pure white snow and the darkish color tones is well shown.
Well done!

Greetings,
Paras

•  
• werdir (11957)
• [2011-01-16 6:00]

Hi Julie,

B&W suits this nicely, a very peaceful scene. The snow cover is beautiful, and your chosen POV captures the winding river and reflections very well. A good choice of aperture to keep everything sharp.

Warm regards,
Werner

•  
• dilshan74 (6696)
• [2011-01-16 6:29]

Absolutely beautiful work of this special place- stunning mood and tonalities-like a dream!

Best wishes,

Dilshan

•  
• mushtaqhussain (13921)
• [2011-01-16 7:13]

Hi Julie.
Lovely scene captured with beautiful glossy reflection of the BG trees on the little water course which is beautifully framed with good details and the B&W tone makes it more interesting composition wise.
Best Regards
mushtaq

•  
• loribird (5561)
• [2011-01-16 7:28]

Another fantastic photo. Absolutely incredible composition, clarity... literally picture peferct. Great job!!

•  
• teamill (10985)
• [2011-01-16 7:43]

Beautiful shot Julie! Love the B&W tones, and the shimmer on the river. Fantastic winter shot. Looks like here... except I suspect our temperatures are a whole lot colder than there :)
Have a nice Sunday
Trudy

•  
• Nenufar (216)
• [2011-01-16 8:11]

Bonito local e foto fantástica.
Muitos parabéns!

•  
• javedraza (557)
• [2011-01-16 8:31]

Hi Julie,

Excellent shot, amazing one I like the way you present it in B&W excellent highlight and good DOF,
very good POV,

Regards,
Javed

•  
• tnahari (26007)
• [2011-01-16 8:33]

Hi Julie
I like this wonderful B&W picture. artistic presentation of a beautiful winter scene.
good display of cold atmosphere.
well captured, composed and framed.
shalom
tsilla

•  
• suprasannac (499)
• [2011-01-16 9:25]

Hi Julie,
Beautiful photograph, great mood of winter , I love the B&W effect and your composition here.
TFS
Suprasanna

•  
• RSK (14753)
• [2011-01-16 12:14]

Hi Julie,Guess I'm the odd man out,but
I must admit I prefer your color version to this one,there's a little more warmth to it.Personally I find with B&W images of this nature that they are more vibrant when the whole image is Tack sharp. In your colored version the tree trunks have much more defination & sharpness than in this image,wonderful winter scene,just wish it had more details & sharpness in the foreground trees.
Best Regards
Ron

•  
• fransx (41704)
• [2011-01-16 14:26]

Hi Julie,
Another fine B&W Winter shot with magnificent details. Very good contrast and a glorious reflection in the water. Details are just fantastic.
My warm regards,

Francis Xavier

•  
• nicou (50772)
• [2011-01-16 22:38]

Hello

Merveilleux décor hiervanle, très bellle vue et compo avec les refelts sur le plan d'eau, entre galce et neige, quelle compo douce, superbe.

Bravo et amitié

Nicou

•  
• shelbeesmom (58278)
• [2011-01-17 7:43]

Gorgeous work Julie! You guys got a nice couple of days of beautiful snow. Now I'm sure you are sick of it! haha! Excellent comp here!
B-)
Linda

•  
• rminkow (34772)
• [2011-01-19 21:22]

Hi Julie..great range of tones...nice work on getting such a wide range...well composed,,,,nice all around.

Roger

•  
• jean11-3 (16374)
• [2011-01-22 5:03]

Hello Julie, I have enjoyed your winter shots,and this study in b/w is an alternative way of looking at this part of your world.
Good composition with the river winding through the scene.The reflection offers a good variety of darker tones to the lighter tones of the snow and the trees.
Tfs, regards Jean.