Members: eMBeer >> Critiques Written

Register

Critiques: Critiques Written | Critiques Received | Comments
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  >

PhotoCritique [Translate]

eMBeer Gold Star Critiquer [C: 237 W: 56 N: 2] (24) [2020-04-24 10:23] [+]

Out of focus, with several overburns. Why did you publish it?!?

eMBeer Gold Star Critiquer [C: 237 W: 56 N: 2] (24) [2020-04-24 10:12]

Great compo, great mood.

eMBeer Gold Star Critiquer [C: 237 W: 56 N: 2] (24) [2018-03-24 13:31]

Hi Musa,
though the motiff and composition of this photo was repeated thousands of times, this one is unique, because is absolutely perfectly balanced in all aspects: composition, light, DOF, details, etc...

eMBeer Gold Star Critiquer [C: 237 W: 56 N: 2] (24) [2018-03-24 13:27] [+]

Hi Michael,
I know that some shots record unique situations, but I expect the photography should keep minimum technical quality. This one does not though...

eMBeer Gold Star Critiquer [C: 237 W: 56 N: 2] (24) [2018-03-24 13:24] [+]

Hi Jack,
nice view, though bottom of the photo doesn't work for me at all. With camera you have I'd expect much better technical quality of this photo.

eMBeer Gold Star Critiquer [C: 237 W: 56 N: 2] (24) [2015-07-11 17:15] [+]

Dynamic photo, but weak composition. Messy background, taking focus out of the girl. Unacceptable blur. If you'd waited a little, she could be taken with almost black background of the door (?) or entry to somewhere. Red hair and pale skin of hers would be emphasized dramatically, giving a lot more of focus to her.

eMBeer Gold Star Critiquer [C: 237 W: 56 N: 2] (24) [2015-07-11 17:10] [+]

Weak composition, very blurry. Was it really worth sharing with us?

eMBeer Gold Star Critiquer [C: 237 W: 56 N: 2] (24) [2015-07-11 17:08]

Very nice compo and - most of all - excellent idea for the photo! tfs

eMBeer Gold Star Critiquer [C: 237 W: 56 N: 2] (24) [2015-07-11 17:07]

Nicely composed. Conversion to b&w ruined strength of this photo. The zebra becomes invisible against the bacground, with partial backlight intensifying this effect. If it was in colour, it would be perfectly distinguishable against green background and surrounding. Just use b&w where you need it (for example when you have too many colours on an interesting shape which you want to emphasize), and not just because.

eMBeer Gold Star Critiquer [C: 237 W: 56 N: 2] (24) [2015-07-11 16:58] [+]

Not every snap is worth publishing. Messy details, lack of composition. I agree with what Jonathan wrote.